Episode 80
Thank you, Squaderinos!
This week Paul and Billy look into three separate missing person cases sent to us by Squaderinos. Susan Osborne and her son Evan disappeared from Holtville, Alabama in May of 2017. Dulce Alavez was abducted from Bridgeton, NJ on...READ ON
Episode 77
MISSING: Morgan Nick
This week Paul and Billy look into the disappearance of Morgan Nick from Alma, Arkansas. Six-year-old Morgan disappeared from a little league field on June 9th, 1995. The case and descriptions of the possible abductor had...READ ON
Episode 76
Are There More Richard Davis Victims?
This week Billy and Paul look into the murder of 5-year-old Siobhan McGuinness from Missoula, Montana. Her case was recently solved with genetic genealogy, but identifying her killer as only brought on more questions. Could...READ ON
Episode 73
The Disappearance of Brianna Maitland
Billy and Paul look into the mysterious disappearance of Brianna Maitland from Montgomery, Vermont. After leaving work on March 19, 2004, her car was found abandoned crashed into a barn. Upon learning she was missing, questions...READ ON
Episode 72
The Humboldt Five, Part 2
Paul and Billy finish their look into the Humboldt Five. They take a deeper look into the disappearances and deaths of Sheila Franks and Danielle Bertolini. Sheila was a single mother of two young children. Danielle was a...READ ON
Episode 71
The Humboldt Five, Part 1
Billy and Paul begin their look into the Humboldt Five with this first part of a two part series. They delve into the missing person cases of Jennifer Wilmer, Karen Mitchell and Christine Walters. Each young woman disappeared...READ ON
Episode 68
MISSING: Lashaya Stine and Brookelyn Farthing
Paul and Billy look into two separate missing person cases this week. The first, 16-year-old Lashaya Stine left her home in Aurora, Colorado on July 16, 2016 around 2 AM. Her mother believes she went out to meet someone but she...READ ON
Episode 56
MISSING: Vanessa Guillen and Kierra Coles
This week Paul and Billy look into two separate missing persons cases. The first is a soldier who went missing while on post. The second is a mail carrier last seen on camera leaving her home. Neither case is related. Each in a...READ ON
Episode 49
Voices of evil: The cases of Amber Tuccaro and Margaret Ellen Fox
This week we brought you two unsolved cases separated by decades, but each is haunted with the voice of the possible offender. Amber Tuccaro. Photos via RCMP. Amber Tuccaro: 20-year-old Amber Tuccaro was a member...READ ON
Episode 44
What Happened to Carole Baskin’s Husband Don Lewis?
Just like everyone else during this quarantine period, Jensen and Holes became enthralled with Netflix's Tiger King: Murder, Mayhem and Madness. But for us the most puzzling question was: Where is Carole Baskin's husband Don...READ ON